Gaza: Archdiocese Distances itself from its own Archbishop

Monsignor Gustavo García-Siller, 67, the Mexican-born Archbishop of San Antonio, Texas, USA, has criticised the Israeli war in Gaza in several messages on Twitter.com (7 May). He urged the "Jewish …More
Monsignor Gustavo García-Siller, 67, the Mexican-born Archbishop of San Antonio, Texas, USA, has criticised the Israeli war in Gaza in several messages on Twitter.com (7 May).
He urged the "Jewish brothers and sisters" to "stop killing Palestinians. STOP!" [However, this war has nothing to do with the "Jewish brothers and sisters", but with a right-wing regime that many Jews oppose].
He added: "Palestinians are dying. Do we care?"
After the Archbishop was accused of "anti-Semitism", his spokesman distanced himself from the remarks: "'The Twitter account of Archbishop Gustavo García-Siller is his personal account; it is not the official account of the Archdiocese of San Antonio. Archbishop Gustavo urges prayers for peace in the Middle East," Jordan McMorrough, director of communications for the Archdiocese of San Antonio, told PillarCatholic.com (9 May).
The Israeli regime, which has occupied the Gaza Strip since 1967, has killed at least 34,789 Gazans, including 14,500 children, since …More
Live Mike
Egypt says it will formally support South Africa’s genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) france24.com/…s-in-gaza-after-issuing-new-rafah-evacuation-order
Alex A
Now, there's a couple of 'upstanding, righteous' countries whom have never ill treated its citizens. 🤫
Live Mike
How many babies in their respective countries have butchered their own children in abortion?
4 more comments from Live Mike
Alex A
"The Israeli regime, which has occupied the Gaza Strip since 1967, has killed at least 34,789 Gazans, including 14,500 children, since October 2023. Over 78,204 people have been injured. More than 8,000 are missing." Where on earth did the above mentioned Bishop get his information from? From a Ouija board, perhaps? Wherever he obtained it, he be better advised by someone in a local bar, who no …More
"The Israeli regime, which has occupied the Gaza Strip since 1967, has killed at least 34,789 Gazans, including 14,500 children, since October 2023. Over 78,204 people have been injured. More than 8,000 are missing." Where on earth did the above mentioned Bishop get his information from? From a Ouija board, perhaps? Wherever he obtained it, he be better advised by someone in a local bar, who no doubt would much more informed. For his Excellence's edification and education, Israel has not occupied the Gaza strip since 2005. Secondly, the figures you quote-presumably from Hamas propaganda videos- are seriously flawed. Hamas are known to both fudge the numbers and also include their own casualties numbers in the overall totals. In short, anyone with a modicum of honesty would not, and could not, rely on Hamas for such data. Finally, Two simple questions for the Bishop, Why do think Egypt gave up its control over the Gazans and why won't they open their borders to the Palestinian refugees? I'm sure your Ouija board will have no difficulty in helping you with such information.
Live Mike
@Alex A How long have you been a Zionist? Was that something you learned at home or were you indoctrinated during your academic years?
Alex A
Live Mike From the days of Ultra Violet 'infamy' I had you pegged as someone I would be less than willing to associate with. From a reliable source, I was informed you once served in the army, which I assume was the Salvation army. Now, should you wish to continue with your dismal comments to my good self, I will accomodate you in kind, fourfold. However, should you move forward with the backbone …More
Live Mike From the days of Ultra Violet 'infamy' I had you pegged as someone I would be less than willing to associate with. From a reliable source, I was informed you once served in the army, which I assume was the Salvation army. Now, should you wish to continue with your dismal comments to my good self, I will accomodate you in kind, fourfold. However, should you move forward with the backbone of a manly Traditional Catholic, demonstrated by an apology and an assurance that you won't block, as been your modus operandi, future comments that I may submit, I will respond without further rancor or disparagement. Do we understand each other?
Live Mike
"I'm really really sorry. I apologize unreservedly. I offer a complete and utter retraction. The imputation was totally without basis in fact, and was in no way fair comment, and was motivated purely by malice, and I deeply regret any distress that my comments may have caused you, or your family, and I hereby undertake not to repeat any such slander at any time in the future."
Alex A
Apology unreservedly accepted. Gracias por tu varonil respuesta
Alex A
@
mccallansteve There is no genocide by Israel. Period! To claim otherwise is tantamount at best, to misinformation and, at worse, outright lying. Suggest you familiarise yourself with Palestinian Constitution where it explicity spells out their aim to rid the land of all Jews. That is genocide! Israels aim, in the current conflict, is to rid Gaza of the existance of a terrorist group called Hamas …More
@

mccallansteve There is no genocide by Israel. Period! To claim otherwise is tantamount at best, to misinformation and, at worse, outright lying. Suggest you familiarise yourself with Palestinian Constitution where it explicity spells out their aim to rid the land of all Jews. That is genocide! Israels aim, in the current conflict, is to rid Gaza of the existance of a terrorist group called Hamas and to free the remaining hostages. Speaking of hostages, that heinious action by Hamas, alone, constitutes a war crime. One vital last point, Since October 7 2023, Hezabolla has rained rockets on Israel on a daily basis, over a 7month period this has amounted to over 3,000 rockets/drones. Combine that with the Houtis, Hamas, and Irans attacks on Israel- a country the size of New Jersey- and it just might, alert your mind and senses to what it must be like for the ordinary Israeli citizen to endure, and why its government is insistant on completely beating Hamas. But I wont hold my breath as experience has taught me- I am a 85yr. Traditional Catholic- that, convincing the uneducated/uninformed that their view is flawed is as difficult as getting a left-handed person to write with their right hand. Perhaps, Martin Luther King articulated best: "Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity."
One more comment from Live Mike
mccallansteve
Amazing how no one can even plead for a genocide to stop without being called an anti-semite.
Sean Johnson
Stopping killing Palestinians is antisemitic.
Live Mike
@123jussi Are you being serious or just being silly?
Naomi Arai
Islam is the problem. They’ll come and murder us, too.
123jussi
So why don’t the Muslims surrender and stop it all?
Alex A
123jussi With Biden undermining Israel, why would Hamas, or indeed any terrorist group surrender. We all need to keep in mind that Israel is beseiged not only by Hamas but also, Hezabollah, Houthis, Isis, and Iran. all have one aim, that is the total destruction of Israel. UN experts now predict that Iran will soon be armed with a Nuclear bomb and you don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure …More
123jussi With Biden undermining Israel, why would Hamas, or indeed any terrorist group surrender. We all need to keep in mind that Israel is beseiged not only by Hamas but also, Hezabollah, Houthis, Isis, and Iran. all have one aim, that is the total destruction of Israel. UN experts now predict that Iran will soon be armed with a Nuclear bomb and you don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out who it is intended for. Then what will the worlds reaction be, I wonder?